East Bay Diner Seaford

Located at 3360 Merrick Rd in Seaford, NY, East Bay Diner Seaford stands as a cherished culinary gem offering classic diner fare with a unique twist. This beloved local spot specializes in hearty American and Mediterranean-inspired dishes, creating an eclectic menu that satisfies any craving from dawn till dusk.

Step inside and you’re immediately wrapped in a warm, inviting atmosphere highlighted by charming nautical décor. The whimsical fish tanks and TV screens add a playful touch, making the space feel both cozy and vibrant. Whether you’re seated by the host’s welcoming greeting or settling into a booth for a casual meal, the ambiance strikes the perfect balance between comforting diner nostalgia and upbeat community hub.

The menu is a treasure trove of satisfying delights. For breakfast lovers, the Breakfast Platter and the French Toast or Waffle Deluxe offer fluffy, perfectly cooked pancakes and rich, golden toasts that melt in your mouth. If you're craving savory, the Gyro Deluxe or Gyro Garden Salad deliver robust Mediterranean flavors wrapped in fresh ingredients. Those with a bigger appetite rave about the Double Bison Burger topped with American cheese, paired perfectly with generous sides of coleslaw and pickles, ensuring every bite bursts with hearty satisfaction.

Seafood enthusiasts will find joy in dishes like the Jumbo Shrimp Parmesan and Stuffed Shrimp Scampi, each plate brimming with succulent seafood bathed in flavorful sauces. And for comfort food aficionados, classics such as Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana and Eggplant Parmigiana provide rich, indulgent layers of cheese, sauce, and perfectly cooked protein or vegetables.

What truly sets East Bay Diner apart is not just the food quality but the generous portions that leave you full and happy, often with leftovers to savor later—a delight confirmed by satisfied diners who appreciate the outstanding value for the price. Customers like Sharon Howley highlight the "amazing" food and "very reasonable" prices, while Naza Yusupova praises the freshness and size of portions, specifically calling out the Bison Deluxe Burger.

No meal here feels complete without indulging in their dessert selection. The Lemon Meringue Pie, their famous Cream Cheesecake (available in classic, fruit, or chocolate varieties), and the assortment of fruit pies provide a sweet finish to any meal. Desserts like the Apple Crumb Cake and Carrot Cake offer a nostalgic warmth, perfect for sharing or treating yourself.

East Bay Diner also shines in its beverage offerings, featuring large fresh-squeezed orange juice and a variety of freshly cut fruits that balance the rich dishes beautifully. Families feel especially welcomed; parents like Kristina Filosa appreciate the kid-friendly meal options like silver dollar pancakes and western omelets that delight younger palates without overwhelming portions.

Service here matches the high culinary standards, with attentive and friendly staff who make every visit feel personalized. Mark H recalls outstanding service from waitress Bobbie, highlighting how thoughtful touches like hot matzo ball soup on a chilly evening enhance the overall dining experience.

For those seeking a diner that combines generous portions, diverse flavors, and a charismatic atmosphere, East Bay Diner Seaford is a standout choice. It promises not only satisfying meals filled with vibrant flavors and comforting familiarity but also a welcoming space where every guest feels like part of the family.

Whether you're a local or just passing through, make time to indulge in the hearty breakfasts, eclectic dinners, and irresistible desserts that have made East Bay Diner a treasured Long Island institution.